Job Market Insight: Nepotism in the Workplace

Ah, nepotism—the age-old practice of playing favorites, where it's no what you know, but who you know. Whether it’s a small family business or a large corporation, nepotism seems to have an uncanny ability to sneak into workplaces across industries. The Rise Community shared some eye-opening (and sometimes eyebrow-raising) experiences around nepotism in the workplace. Let’s dive in and explore how favoritism can influence the job market and what it means for employees trying to climb the career ladder the honest way.

✨ Are you a job seeker in New York? Check out these curated jobs in your area!

Understanding Nepotism in the Workplace

Nepotism is not just an annoyance—it’s a systemic issue that affects workplace dynamics, employee morale, and overall productivity. At its core, nepotism is the practice of hiring or promoting someone based on personal relationships rather than merit or qualifications. While it’s more prevalent in family-run businesses, it can also be found in large organizations where leaders prioritize their networks over a fair recruitment process.

A 2021 study by the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) found that nepotism and favoritism can lead to significant inefficiencies in organizations. When employees are hired or promoted due to their connections rather than their skills or performance, it can result in decreased overall productivity. The study also highlighted that these practices could lead to a lack of diversity, which stifles innovation and creativity—a crucial component for businesses looking to thrive in competitive markets.

Furthermore, a survey by the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) revealed that 23% of employees felt that nepotism was a significant problem in their workplace, leading to a lack of trust in management and a negative impact on employee engagement. When employees perceive the hiring process as biased, it diminishes their motivation to perform at their best, knowing that advancement opportunities are limited to a select few.

Nepotism Is Everywhere

For some of our community members, nepotism is as common as Monday morning meetings. Take User CA ⭐, who stated bluntly, "I've encountered ONLY this. Ever." Clearly, some workplaces don’t even try to hide it. It’s almost as if favoritism is written into the company’s mission statement.

User FN ⭐, an Operations Associate, pointed out that while nepotism is often ignored, some even “applaud it if it’s working in their favor.” It seems like a case of “it’s only a problem when it’s not benefiting me.” But favoritism, as convenient as it may seem, can have serious consequences for morale and productivity, making workplaces feel more like exclusive clubs than teams.

It’s Who You Know, Not What You Know

User TC ⭐, an Operations Manager, summed up the reality many of us face: “The truth of business is that it's not what you know, but who you know.” While networking and personal connections are part of building a career, they shouldn’t be the sole determinant for job opportunities. Unfortunately, for some, it often feels that way. User CR ⭐, who recently moved from Rhode Island, quipped, "I just moved out of Rhode Island; their state sport is nepotism." Clearly, in some places, favoritism isn't just common—it's practically an institution.

Research from Harvard Business Review indicates that nepotism can damage organizational culture by creating an "in-group" versus "out-group" dynamic, where those who are not part of the favored circle feel isolated and undervalued. This division can result in reduced collaboration and poor communication, ultimately impacting team performance.

From College Connections to Family Ties

Some stories from the Rise Community reveal how deep nepotism can run. User FM ⭐, a Senior Product Experience Strategist, shared his experience at a company where the CEO and senior leaders were all Dartmouth alumni. “Somehow circumvented the ‘proper’ HR channels and processes and did what they wanted,” he recalls. A tight-knit network can sometimes feel more like an impenetrable wall to those on the outside.

User HR ⭐ witnessed a similar situation in her time at a large retailer, where leadership positions were handed out to the owner’s children and their friends, who often lacked the necessary qualifications. It’s frustrating enough to compete against equally qualified candidates, but it’s downright demoralizing when you're up against someone with a last name that gets them a foot in the door.

Nepotism and Layoffs: A Brutal Combination

Some stories go beyond just favoritism in hiring and promotions—they highlight how nepotism can affect layoffs and job security. One anonymous community member recounted working at a small, privately-owned company filled with relatives. When the company faced slow sales and had to lay off 10% of the staff, none of the relatives were let go, even those with far less seniority than others. “As a matter of fact, one laid-off employee trained several said relatives who kept their jobs,” they shared. It’s a tough pill to swallow when fairness and meritocracy are thrown out the window in favor of family loyalty.

This scenario aligns with findings from a 2022 Glassdoor study, which showed that 35% of employees who experienced nepotism reported lower job satisfaction and were more likely to leave their jobs within a year. When people see that layoffs or promotions are not based on merit, it can create a toxic work environment where trust in management is lost.

There Are Exceptions, But...

Not everyone has experienced nepotism to the same degree. User BT ⭐, a UX Designer, mentions working in small family-owned companies where people were hired based on skills, not bloodlines. While nepotism wasn’t overtly at play, she acknowledged that it can be a significant issue in workplaces, especially in smaller companies where hiring decisions are more personal and less structured.

User KK ⭐, another community member, has seen nepotism in the form of summer internships for the owner's or director’s kids, which he found somewhat understandable. However, he emphasized that he hasn't witnessed it impacting full-time hiring decisions—yet. It appears that nepotism can manifest in varying degrees, sometimes as harmless favors, other times as career-altering decisions.

Nepotism Creates Tension and Unfairness

The impact of nepotism goes beyond just the person who gets the job or promotion. It can create a ripple effect of resentment and frustration among other employees. An anonymous community member humorously described a situation where the owner's nephew “took the reins for a presentation” and basically “drew inspiration” from their ideas. It’s a subtle way of saying their work was “borrowed” without acknowledgment. When favoritism and bias lead to an environment where credit isn’t given where it’s due, it demotivates employees and creates a toxic culture.

Is Nepotism Really a Thing of the Past?

While some, like User EC ⭐, believe nepotism isn’t as common in developed countries anymore, the survey results suggest otherwise. Nepotism may not always be blatant, but it certainly lurks in the shadows of many workplaces. And when it does show up, it often results in unfair advantages, unqualified hires, and a general lack of trust in the organization’s leadership.

Navigating Nepotism: What Can You Do?

1. Recognize the Signs: Knowing when nepotism is at play is half the battle. Look for patterns in hiring, promotions, or special projects that favor certain individuals based on personal connections rather than merit.

2. Stay Professional: If you suspect nepotism, maintain your professionalism. Focus on your work, document your achievements, and ensure you’re creating a strong, undeniable track record.

3. Speak Up Tactfully: If you feel comfortable, bring up concerns to a manager or HR. Frame it as a discussion about ensuring fairness and a positive workplace culture, rather than pointing fingers.

4. Know When to Move On: If nepotism is affecting your growth and well-being, it may be time to consider greener pastures. A healthy work environment should value skills, effort, and contribution over personal connections.

🚀 Join Rise today and get your dream job in Account Management and beyond!

Nepotism is an unfortunate reality in many workplaces, but it doesn’t have to define your career journey. While it can feel disheartening to see favoritism undermine merit and fairness, remember that you'r not alone. The stories shared by the Rise Community reveal that this is a widespread issue, but also one that can be navigated with awareness and strategy.

When faced with nepotism, it’s crucial to stay true to your values and focus on what you can control—your skills, your work ethic, and your professional development. If you find yourself in an environment where nepotism overshadows opportunity, consider it a sign to look for companies that prioritize transparency, equity, and meritocracy.

Ultimately, the best way to combat nepotism is to thrive in spite of it. Build relationships based on respect and authenticity, advocate for fair practices, and seek out workplaces where merit and hard work are truly rewarded. Remember, while nepotism might give some people a head start, it’s those who run the race with integrity, passion, and talent who truly go the distance.